I love doing movie reviews and today I’m going to do three movies instead of just one. The thing is, they’re all the same movie redone over and over.
Before we officially begin, I’ll have to say that I really liked the book “Little Women” by Louisa May Alcott. However, when a book is adapted to a movie it doesn’t always turn out. (i.e., you miss most of the story.) But I’m going to quickly review three versions of this classic book. I’m not going to delve into the details of the story, but I’m going to do short reviews of the movies themselves.
1. Little Women: 1933
This is an entirely black and white film (which doesn’t bother me at all) and it’s extremely cute and quaint. Though the film is supposed to be set during the American Civil War, its actors have an unmistakably ’20’s and ’30’s look.
Left to right: Amy, Beth, Jo, and Meg March
Starring Katherine Hepburn as the tomboy, Jo March. She does a really good job, despite the “dramatic” acting style of the time.
While a cute old movie, this version omits a lot from the book that probably would have helped the viewer understand the characters better. But it is a movie, so I know you can’t put in everything or we’d be sitting there for hours. Still, perhaps just a little more character development – like between Jo and Laurie, or even between the sisters themselves – would have made things more clear.
But I really enjoyed this little movie, fake eyelashes, lipstick, and all. If you like old movies, then this one is probably for you.
2. Little Women: 1949
This version of Little Women was filmed after World War II, the bright red lipstick and fake eyelashes prevail. I love ’40’s style makeup, but since the movie is supposed to be set during the American Civil War, it doesn’t quite fit in.
Left to right: Amy, Beth, Jo, and Meg March
But that’s a little nit-picky, so let’s get on with the rest of the review. Again, Jo was really good, played this time by June Allyson. Elizabeth Taylor played Amy March, but it’s difficult to think of her as anything but Cleopatra.
I found it a little strange, however, that this film is almost exactly the same as the ’33 version. The script is almost the same, the house is the same, the screenplay is the same, the music is the same, and even Amy’s school teacher is the same actor. (It’s got that little tune that easily gets stuck in your head – I’ll let you decide whether that’s good or not.)
At any rate, I enjoyed it, even if it didn’t stick exactly to the book. Either way, it’s another cute old movie!
3. Little Women: 2017 TV Series
The BBC put out a three part miniseries of Little Women a handful of years ago (pretty recent, actually). I have to say, I was a little leery of this version. While I’ve said before that the other ones don’t really exactly follow the books, I was worried that this one would be even worse. Boy, was I wrong.
Left to right: Beth, Jo, Amy, and Meg March
This beautiful miniseries followed the book so closely that they even kept in the part where Amy (Kathryn Newton) tries to make a plaster casting of her foot.
This cast is by far my favorite. I don’t even know where to start here but to just say that they were all incredible. But I have to say a quick word for Marmee (Emily Watson). She has won so many awards over the years and should have won one for this.
And Angela Lansbury makes an appearance as Aunt March.
And Laurie (Jonah Haur-King) was the best out of all the other Lauries. And Jo (Maya Hawke) – ah, nevermind! Just watch it!
The costumes were gorgeous and so was the scenery. I mean, they did everything right. (You’ll probably never hear me say that one.)
One of my favorite parts in the whole series is a little music montage to “Land o’ the Leal” beautifully sung by Annes Elwy (who played Beth.)
This one is not a remake of the other two; it’s a completely new take on the same book, and with its original soundtrack, fresh scenery, and amazing actors, this one is by far my favorite version, and is one of my favorite movies in general. Definitely a must-see.
I enjoyed them all in different ways, and it was really fun to see the different eras make the same movie. So all in all, I would definitely recommend these movies!
♥Amara